Ignatius of Loyola provides spiritual depth by describing the ebb and flow of the Christian life in his fourteen rules of spiritual discernment. Recognizing that one is either moving toward God or away from God (the first and second rules) leads one toward consolation (a state of being close to God) or desolation (when the soul feels distant from God).[1] The key point is that followers of Jesus move fluidly between periods of consolation and desolation.[2] In periods of desolation, God wants us to move out of that state and into consolation. But how we move out is important. This essay will focus on Rule Six of Ignatian spiritual discernment, concentrating on movement during desolation in a trajectory into consolation.
In Rule Six of the fourteen rules of spiritual discernment, Ignatius reminds us of Rule Five: we are not to make any big changes during periods of desolation. However, we are to increase our use and practice of spiritual disciplines.[3] Rule Six focuses on what should change, not what should not.[4] Specifically, what should change is an increase in four elements of the spiritual life: prayer, meditation, examination, and suitable penance.[5]
Prayer matters because it reverses the feeling of drifting away from God and moves us toward him.[6] I know in my life that when I am in that period of desolation, my prayer life is one of the first things to suffer. Even with my directees, I notice that prayer is usually the first thing left behind. Even in a time of difficult consolation (when we are moving toward God, but our life circumstances are difficult), prayer plugs one of the holes in the wall of our spiritual defenses.[7]
The next element is meditation. By filling our minds with “the sustaining truth of God’s faithful love as a source of hope in time of distress,” we start to counter the thoughts the enemy puts into our consciousness.[8] So many times I have let those thoughts of despair and separation take hold. By practicing Christian meditation, I intentionally fill my imagination with the things of God and dwell on his love and presence. When my directees feel at a loss in their desolation, teaching them to meditate in a way that fills them with the love of Jesus can help in turning the tide of negativity.
Ignatius also calls the person in desolation to “much examination.”[9] This examination is a method of looking at the moments of life daily (or more often) and asking God where he was and how we are to respond to him. Essentially, it is a discipline that combats the diversion of our minds away from God.[10] Examination is also crucial for recognizing false consolation, when we think we are in consolation but are actually moving away from God.[11] Maybe my directee wants their life to be on track, but they sound too confident, and their actions betray a different state. By taking frequent examinations, we allow the Holy Spirit to correct us and help us reverse course.
Lastly, Ignatius prescribes some “suitable way of doing penance.”[12] For my Protestant sensibilities, this concept is difficult to grasp at first. But Ignatius is not referring to some masochistic flagellation. Instead, he directs us to engage in practices that “energize in a spiritually healthy way and aid in overcoming desolation itself.”[13] Here, I can go beyond prayer, meditation, and examination and engage other spiritual disciplines such as fasting, solitude, the Eucharist, and others. Penance is not pain, but activity.
When I or my directee is in desolation, there are several things to remember to move out of that state. When I am intentionally optimistic and name out loud the good things of God, when I remember that this is only a temporary state and that consolation is on the way, when I am reminded that God’s love is present even though I don’t feel it, I can make progress away from the enemy towards the life-giving presence of Jesus.[14] Rule six offers four ways to remember these important truths. In my times of desolation, and in guiding my directees through their own times, the sixth rule offers direction away from the enemy’s distractions.
[1] Ignatius of Loyola, The Spiritual Exercises: With a Practical Guide & Appendix of Prayers, trans. Elder Mullan (Rex Mundi Press, 2025), 104–5.
[2] Mark E. Thibodeaux, Ignatian Discernment of the Spirits: For Spiritual Direction and Pastoral Care (Loyola Press, 2020) x.
[3] Ignatius of Loyola, The Spiritual Exercises: With a Practical Guide & Appendix of Prayers, 105.
[4] Timothy M. Gallagher, The Discernment of Spirits: An Ignatian Guide for Everyday Living (Crossroad Pub. Co., 2005), 85.
[5] Ignatius of Loyola, The Spiritual Exercises: With a Practical Guide & Appendix of Prayers, 105.
[6] Gallagher, The Discernment of Spirits, 86.
[7] Thibodeaux, Ignatian Discernment of the Spirits: For Spiritual Direction and Pastoral Care, 87–88.
[8] Gallagher, The Discernment of Spirits, 88.
[9] Gallagher, The Discernment of Spirits, 105.
[10] Gallagher, The Discernment of Spirits, 91.
[11] Thibodeaux, Ignatian Discernment of the Spirits: For Spiritual Direction and Pastoral Care, 93.
[12] Ignatius of Loyola, The Spiritual Exercises: With a Practical Guide & Appendix of Prayers, 105.
[13] Gallagher, The Discernment of Spirits, 92.
[14] Thibodeaux, Ignatian Discernment of the Spirits: For Spiritual Direction and Pastoral Care, 79–80.


